McDuffies Bakery

Reviews

• Lauren S.

  star star star star star 29 May 2026

  There was a group of women at the dog park that couldn't stop ranting and raving about this place. I had the idea in my head that it was a restaurant that served pot pies, so I was surprised when I walked in and it was just a bakery.
  You walk in and there are so many delicious pastries, cupcakes, cookies, breads, pot pies and soups. There are samples available of many of their treats.
  I was able to taste the chicken pot pie filling, and I was hooked right away. I went straight to the freezer and bought one to make at home. I also bought a cinnamon bun and it was so delicious!
  Two days later, (Today) I made the chicken pot pie. And it was the very best I've ever had. The crust was so butter and delicious. The vegetables were so fresh and beautiful. The pie was fantastic!
  We will definitely be going here again. Though I wish they sold single hot pot pies in the store. I suggest you think about opening a restaurant!

• Kristie S.

  star star star star star 22 May 2026

  *Update* The Seafood Pot Pie is too much for me and I love seafood. We bought the single serve to try it out and I'm glad we did.
  
  This was our first visit to Mr. Pot Pie McDuffies Bakery and it's really nice inside and the food is great!
  
  They have samples at the front of pastries and bread. I wish they offered samples of the pot pies, because they're pricey and it would be disappointing to spend $20-30 (after taxes) on one and not like it.
  
  We purchased the Turkey Bacon Gouda Pot Pie and it was AMAZING! It had big chunks of turkey, potatoes and tiny bacon chunks, similar to bacon bits BUT the bacon did NOT taste like crappy container bacon bits from the grocery store! The bacon is actually applewood smoked bacon. The Gouda cheese was actually a sauce and was so yummy!!
  
  The corn bread is ok. It tastes a little too much like corn.
  
  We also bought the Lemon Blueberry Bread and it's so yummy too! It has a nice crumbly icing and Blueberry chunks.
  
  The reason why I gave this place 5 stars instead of 4 (based off of price) is because it would cost almost as much to buy all the ingredients to the make the Turkey Bacon Gouda Pot Pie AND we'd have to cut everything up and bake it.
  
  Definitely check out a Mr. Pot Pie McDuffies bakery!

• Shawn F.

  star star star star star_border 20 May 2026

  I was given a pot pie as a gift from this place & had to track it down, as this area has been bereft of bakeries for a while now.  Interesting to say the least & a concept that has potential to grow.

• Kevin M.

  star star star star star_border 12 May 2026

  This place is pretty good. I've gotten a few of the pot pies and they have all been solid, turkey Gouda being my favorite. Right on the edge of being overpriced but still reasonable in my opinion. To go out and buy everything to make one pot pie would run you the same plus your time.
  
  The soups are all good, seafood bisque is excellent. Not sure if they are scratch made or not but they are tasty.
  
  Only thing I've ever gotten out of the bakery is the potato, cheddar and bacon scone. Man is that delicious. Take it home, toast it up with a little butter and your in heaven.
  
  Strange that they are closed on Sunday mornings as that seems like a good time to go get some coffee and baked goods. I've walked up there a couple times forgetting they are closed. Nice to give employees a break but seems like a few hours on Sunday mornings could be lucrative.
  
  Always friendly staff in there too.

• Megan S.

  star star star star star 8 May 2026

  I stopped in for the seafood bisque and also picked up a seafood pot pie for my in laws. The soup was a large portion for a small size ($4.99) and it came with a fresh roll. Very delicious and full of yummy seafood flavor. I ate half and saved the rest for my husband to try and he couldn't get enough! Told me next time bring home the large which is only $7.99. My mother in law text me after eating the pot pie saying "it was out of this world!" I was so pleased they enjoyed it and look forward to trying it myself next time! Bright, clean shop with very friendly service. I look forward to going back.